Insurance for Collectibles and High-Value Items

April 9, 2025 | Insurance

For many, collectibles and high-value items represent more than just material possessions—they are treasures that hold deep sentimental value and can also be significant financial assets. Whether it’s rare artwork, vintage jewelry, limited-edition cars, or rare coins, these items often carry substantial worth. But standard homeowner’s or renter’s insurance may not fully cover these precious belongings in the event of damage, loss, or theft.

In this blog, we’ll delve into why you need specialized insurance for collectibles and high-value items, how it works, and why having the right coverage is crucial. If you're in Tempe , Phoenix , Scottsdale , Tucson , Gilbert , or Chandler , we'll help guide you through the process of insuring your valuable possessions properly.

Many individuals assume that their homeowner’s or renter’s insurance policy will fully cover high-value items. However, this is often not the case. Here's why:

Under-coverage for Expensive Items: Most standard homeowner’s policies have limits for personal property coverage , often capping claims for valuable items like art, jewelry , and antiques at relatively low amounts—typically around $1,000 or $2,000 per item. This is far from adequate for rare and valuable items. Limited Protection for Specialized Items: Some unique items, such as rare coins, classic cars, or sports memorabilia, may not be covered under standard policies at all. These require specialized insurance tailored to their value and risk factors. Depreciation : Homeowner’s insurance often provides reimbursement based on the depreciated value of items, which means if your collectibles or high-value items are damaged or lost, you could receive far less than their replacement value.

To make sure your collectibles and high-value possessions are fully protected, you may want to look into specialized insurance options. Here are some common types of coverage that are available for these items:

1. Scheduled Personal Property Coverage

Scheduled personal property coverage is an add-on to your homeowner’s or renter’s policy that specifically insures valuable items like jewelry, art, or rare antiques. With this coverage, you’ll list individual items separately, ensuring they’re covered for their full value.

What’s covered: Art, jewelry, rare coins, fine wine, luxury watches, and other high-value items. Benefits: This coverage eliminates the limits typically associated with standard policies, offering full protection for each scheduled item against theft , loss, or damage.

2. Valuable Items Insurance

Valuable items insurance provides coverage for high-value items that may be too expensive to be fully covered under a standard homeowner's or renter's insurance policy. This type of policy can be customized to suit the specific needs of your collection.

What’s covered: Valuable items like rare artworks, limited-edition collectibles, vintage cars, and luxury jewelry. Benefits: This specialized insurance often includes “all-risk” coverage, meaning you’re protected for virtually any type of damage, whether it's accidental, theft, or mysterious disappearance.

3. Fine Art Insurance

If you own fine art, a specialized fine art insurance policy offers tailored protection for these high-value items. This coverage typically goes beyond the standard limits of homeowner’s insurance.

What’s covered: Paintings, sculptures, rare photographs, and other valuable pieces of art. Benefits: Fine art policies not only cover the full market value of your art but also provide additional protections, including coverage for transit, restoration, and exhibition.

4. Antique and Jewelry Insurance

If you own valuable antiques or high-end jewelry, separate coverage may be necessary to protect these items properly.

What’s covered: Antiques like furniture, rare coins, vintage watches, engagement rings, necklaces, and other fine jewelry. Benefits: Jewelry and antique policies typically offer replacement or repair coverage for the full market value of your items, ensuring you get adequate reimbursement if they’re lost, damaged, or stolen.

5. Classic Car Insurance

Classic cars can be particularly valuable, especially if they’re rare or in mint condition. Standard auto insurance doesn’t always provide the level of protection that classic car collectors need.

What’s covered: Classic, vintage, or rare cars. Benefits: Classic car insurance provides specialized coverage for things like agreed-upon value, restoration, and repair costs, ensuring that if your car is damaged, you’re compensated for its full value, not its depreciated worth.

To make sure you have the right coverage, it’s essential to accurately assess the value of your collectibles and high-value items. Here are some steps to take:

Professional Appraisal: Hiring a certified appraiser is the most reliable way to determine the value of your high-value items. An appraiser will consider factors like rarity, condition, provenance, and market demand. Documentation: Keep detailed records of your collectibles. This includes receipts, certificates of authenticity, photographs, and appraisals. These documents will help you prove the value of your items and make the claims process easier if needed. Review Your Coverage Regularly : The market value of your collectibles can change over time. Regularly review your insurance policy to ensure the value of your items is up-to-date, especially if your collection grows or appreciates in value.

While specialized insurance offers comprehensive protection, there are certain risks that may not be covered. It’s important to be aware of these limitations:

Intentional Damage: Insurance will not cover damages caused by deliberate actions, such as vandalism or self-inflicted harm. Wear and Tear: Normal deterioration due to age, use, or environmental factors may not be covered. This is especially relevant for antique furniture or artwork, which may naturally age over time. Exclusions for Specific Risks: Some policies may exclude certain types of damage, like damage caused by floods or earthquakes. Be sure to check whether you need to purchase additional coverage for these risks.

If you're located in Tempe, Phoenix, Scottsdale, Tucson, Gilbert, or Chandler, working with a local insurance agent is crucial in ensuring your collectibles and high-value items are protected. An experienced agent can help you tailor coverage to your specific needs, advise you on the best policy for your valuables, and help you navigate any potential exclusions or limitations.

At Riseson Insurance , we offer specialized insurance options to help protect your valuable items. Whether you own fine art, vintage cars, or rare jewelry, we’ll ensure that your treasures are covered properly. Call us at 602-460-5470 to learn more about insuring your collectibles and high-value items.

Why Specialized Insurance for Collectibles?

Types of Insurance Coverage for High-Value Items

How to Determine the Value of Your Collectibles

What’s Not Covered by Insurance for Collectibles?

Working with a Local Agent

  • Under-coverage for Expensive Items: Most standard homeowner’s policies have limits for personal property coverage , often capping claims for valuable items like art, jewelry , and antiques at relatively low amounts—typically around $1,000 or $2,000 per item. This is far from adequate for rare and valuable items.
  • Limited Protection for Specialized Items: Some unique items, such as rare coins, classic cars, or sports memorabilia, may not be covered under standard policies at all. These require specialized insurance tailored to their value and risk factors.
  • Depreciation : Homeowner’s insurance often provides reimbursement based on the depreciated value of items, which means if your collectibles or high-value items are damaged or lost, you could receive far less than their replacement value.
  • What’s covered: Art, jewelry, rare coins, fine wine, luxury watches, and other high-value items.
  • Benefits: This coverage eliminates the limits typically associated with standard policies, offering full protection for each scheduled item against theft , loss, or damage.
  • What’s covered: Valuable items like rare artworks, limited-edition collectibles, vintage cars, and luxury jewelry.
  • Benefits: This specialized insurance often includes “all-risk” coverage, meaning you’re protected for virtually any type of damage, whether it's accidental, theft, or mysterious disappearance.
  • What’s covered: Paintings, sculptures, rare photographs, and other valuable pieces of art.
  • Benefits: Fine art policies not only cover the full market value of your art but also provide additional protections, including coverage for transit, restoration, and exhibition.
  • What’s covered: Antiques like furniture, rare coins, vintage watches, engagement rings, necklaces, and other fine jewelry.
  • Benefits: Jewelry and antique policies typically offer replacement or repair coverage for the full market value of your items, ensuring you get adequate reimbursement if they’re lost, damaged, or stolen.
  • What’s covered: Classic, vintage, or rare cars.
  • Benefits: Classic car insurance provides specialized coverage for things like agreed-upon value, restoration, and repair costs, ensuring that if your car is damaged, you’re compensated for its full value, not its depreciated worth.
  • Professional Appraisal: Hiring a certified appraiser is the most reliable way to determine the value of your high-value items. An appraiser will consider factors like rarity, condition, provenance, and market demand.
  • Documentation: Keep detailed records of your collectibles. This includes receipts, certificates of authenticity, photographs, and appraisals. These documents will help you prove the value of your items and make the claims process easier if needed.
  • Review Your Coverage Regularly : The market value of your collectibles can change over time. Regularly review your insurance policy to ensure the value of your items is up-to-date, especially if your collection grows or appreciates in value.
  • Intentional Damage: Insurance will not cover damages caused by deliberate actions, such as vandalism or self-inflicted harm.
  • Wear and Tear: Normal deterioration due to age, use, or environmental factors may not be covered. This is especially relevant for antique furniture or artwork, which may naturally age over time.
  • Exclusions for Specific Risks: Some policies may exclude certain types of damage, like damage caused by floods or earthquakes. Be sure to check whether you need to purchase additional coverage for these risks.